Visitors since
2/13/2001


 

 

 

 

www.afte.org > Training Seminar > 2007 Wednesday

Help with the siteClick here to return to the Home Page

 
Wednesday, May 30th

Sunday | Monday | Tuesday | Wednesday | Thursday | Banquet | Friday | Vendors


Morning Technical Session

Morning Moderator: Chris Coleman                  Technical Session: Grand Ballroom A

 

 

8:00 AM

 

General Announcements

 

 

AFTE 2007 Committee Member

 

 

 

8:05 AM

 

Breech Face Castings: An Evaluation of Three Products

J. Justine Davis – Ondogoa County Center for Forensic Science – Syracuse, NY

   
Casting can be used in firearms identification in both training and casework purposes for replication of various surfaces. Three different products available for casting will be evaluated. Mikrosil, Theftingate, and Forensic Sil. This presentation will focus on casting breech faces, and the pros and cons of each product.


 

8:20 AM

 

Modern Methods of Shooting Scene Documentation

 

 

Doreen Hudson – Los Angeles Police Department – Los Angeles, CA

Tony Grissm – Public Safety & Forensics Account Manager – Leica Geosystems

   
Objectives: Contrast the fundamentals of crime scene documentation with state of the art techniques currently available. A discussion of software programs, measuring devices and 3-D laser scanning technology that now support the field of crime scene reconstruction.

Methodology: A survey of specialized equipment used in a modern police agency including Photography, Sketching, Total Station survey equipment, 3-D modeling, animations and 3-D laser scanning.

Results: Examples of each type, in addition to a live demonstration of a 3-D Laser scanner will give the students a comprehensive overview of the advantages and tradeoffs of this low cost to high tech equipment.

Conclusions: Students will be able to make informed decisions about what type of system is best for the type of scene documentation needed in their respective jurisdictions.


8:50 AM

 

 

Matching Cast Bullets to the Moulds that Made Them and Comparisons of Consecutively Manufactured Bullet Molds

 

 

Luke Haag – Forensic Science Services Inc. – Carefree, AZ

   
At least two articles have appeared in the AFTE Journal regarding the comparison of cast bullets with the mould that cast them. The authors [Kellet-July 1984 and Kreiser July 1995] come to opposite conclusions as to whether a cast bullet can be associated with a specific mould. One view is that such bullets can be associated with a specific, individual mould cavity while the other author cautions that you may only be able to say that a cast bullet came from one of a group of closely related moulds.

Following a brief illustrated description of the method used to manufacture bullet moulds and the various locations and sources of tool marks on these moulds, the author will demonstrate that both authors are right and that the correct interpretation of the tool marks on a cast bullet and any putative mould submitted for comparison require a firm understanding and recognition of class characteristics, subclass characteristics and individual characteristics.


 

9:10 AM

 

Who Killed Sammy Weaver at Ruby Ridge?

 

 

Luke Haag – Forensic Science Services Inc. – Carefree, AZ

   
During the initial shootout in August of 2002 at a place called the “Y” on Caribou Ridge, Randy Weaver’s son sustained two perforating gunshot wounds, one of which proved fatal. This wound was the consequence of a bullet that entered the boy’s back, perforated the heart and exited his chest. This bullet was never found during the original investigation and scene processing.

At the time of the criminal trial in the spring of 1993 the possible source of the fatal wound was one of two 5.56mm M16A2 rifles carried by two U.S. Marshals or a suppressed 9mm Colt SMG carried by a third U.S. Marshal.

The boy’s father, Randy Weaver was also nearby and fired a number of 9mm rounds into the air with a Tanfoglio TZ75 pistol.

A family friend of the Weavers also fired shots at the “Y” with a .30-’06 rifle but he and Randy Weaver were never seriously considered as the source of Sammy Weaver’s fatal wound.

The author opined in the 1993 criminal trial that the 5.56mm rifles were excluded as having fired the fatal shot and that a bullet from the 9mm SMG was the probable source of the boy’s fatal gunshot wound. This opinion was based on the nature of the bullet holes in the boy’s leather vest and underlying clothing and the limited choices of bullet types and calibers fired at the “Y”.

During the 1995 senate hearings on what came to be known as “The Siege at Ruby Ridge”, there was a suggestion that Randy Weaver accidentally shot his son with a stray bullet from one of his 9mm pistol shots. Working independently and out of a compelling desire to definitively known what happened on Ruby Ridge, Boundary County Sheriff Greg Sprungl and his close friend, Curt Kastens from the Idaho Department of Law Enforcement, conducted an exhaustive search of the field of fire at the initial shootout scene during the fall of 1995. They recovered numerous bullets after tracking their flight paths through the dense forest and undergrowth. Among these bullets was Sammy Weaver’s fatal bullet- a partially expanded 9mm SilverTip from the Colt 9mm SMG.

This presentation will show how this bullet was located and how it was association with the boy’s fatal gunshot wound through exterior, terminal and wound ballistics as well as trace evidence considerations.


 

9:30 AM

 

BREAK – Held in the Vendor / Exhibitor Area – Grand Ballroom B & C

 

 

Sponsored by: CyberNational, Inc.

     

10:00 AM

 

DOOR PRIZE DRAWINGS

     

10:10 AM

 

Firearm Recoil Dynamics: The Effect of Handgun Gripping on Bullet Velocity

 

 

Alexander Jason – ANITE Group – Pinole, CA

   
The central question examines the belief that a bullet fired from a handgun held with a loose or “limp” grip will show a decrease in velocity. This paper presents the results of dynamic tests in which handguns were fired while unsupported and suspended allowing the handgun to recoil freely in a direction opposite to the bullet’s path and compares the resultant bullet velocities with those produced from a supported grip. A novel trigger activating device was utilized along with a Doppler ballistic radar system to demonstrate that the gripping of the firearm has no effect on bullet velocity.


 

10:30 AM

 

Drive by Shooting: To Dream the Impossible Dream

 

 

Alexander Jason – ANITE Group – Pinole, CA

   
A woman is fatally shot while in the driver’s seat. Husband claims it was a drive-by shooting from an oncoming car. The primary question became: Is this possible?

A shooting incident analysis and reconstruction was performed using all available physical evidence and the integration of data from wound ballistics, velocity calculations, firearms performance, experimental video analysis, and 3D computer animation graphics. The analysis and reconstruction allowed a finding that the evidence was not consistent with the drive-by shooting scenario. This paper presents the methodology and analytical measures used.


 

10:55 AM

 

Video of 4 Ricochet Surfaces

 

 

Jim Roberts – Ventura County Sheriff’s Forensic Laboratory – Ventura, CA

   
Objectives: The two experiments presented were designed to look at the actions of bullets during ricochet events. Shots were fired onto the surface of each of four media.

Methodology: This presentation uses high-speed video and still images taken at the Yuma Proving Ground to demonstrate bullet actions following ricochet from 4 different surfaces. The surfaces are concrete, wallboard, steel and asphalt. The cameras used are Redlake HG-100K cameras. One sequence also uses a high-speed Infer-Red camera by Indigo systems. One of each test will be presented though 3 shots were filmed of each.

Results: The presentation will allow the viewer to see for themselves what actions the bullets go through during ricochet. Including but not limited to the Yaw characteristics that occur.

Conclusions: As has been noted in literature on the subject bullets ricocheting from softer surfaces tend to go higher. Bullets off of hard surfaces tend to yaw nose down.


 

11:10 AM

 

Glock Enhanced Bullet Identification System (EBIS) Barrels

 

 

Judy Chin & Benjamin Sampson – Centre of Forensic Sciences – Toronto, Canada

 

 


Objectives: To determine whether or not projectiles fired from EBIS barrels are of significant value for microscopic examination.

  1. General description of manufacturing process

  2. Methodology/materials

  3. Examination and blind study

  4. Results and conclusions

Methodology: Received four barrels and generated test fires using each barrel with a Glock, Model 22, .40 S&W calibre receiver and magazine from collection. Ammunition used: Winchester Ranger .40S&W, 180 gr. SXT and Winchester .40 S&W calibre, 155gr. FMJ truncated cone.

Compared test fires of both bullet profiles to one another within one barrel and against different barrels.

Blind study: scientist received known and unknown bullets to be microscopically compared to determine whether or not reproducibility of the rifling characteristics could be observed in the control samples and to determine whether or not the unknown samples could be identified to the correct barrel.

 


 

     

11:30 AM

 

LUNCH (on your own)

 

 

 

 

  Afternoon Technical Session

Afternoon Moderator:  Nancy McCombs

 

 

1:00 PM

 

DOOR PRIZE DRAWINGS

 

 

 

1:10 PM

 

Headstamp Impressions in Breech Face Residues

 

 

David Lane – Arizona Department of Public Safety – Flagstaff, AZ

 

 


This research was conducted as a requirement for completing the 2006 National Firearms Examiner Academy and serves to raise awareness regarding headstamp impressions in breech face residues. Examples have been noted in casework in which soft residues have accumulated on a breech face and retain an impressed headstamp image of the last discharged cartridge. Firearms of various calibers were examined to determine the probability of residues accumulating, if headstamp impressions remained in the residue, and the effects of residues on breech marks. The results showed that .22 caliber rimfire firearms could have headstamp impressions remaining in residues. Along with firing pin impression orientation, these were useful in determining the last cartridge to be discharged. Hypothetical reconstruction scenarios are used to demonstrate how this finding may be useful in supporting or refuting witness accounts. On the other hand, centerfire calibers examined in this study were not likely to have accumulations of residues. When soft residues were applied directly to the breech there were not significant effects on centerfire primer breech marks.

 

1:40 PM

 

Shotgun Pellet Patterns: Pellet Distribution and the Effect of Pellet Deformation

 

 

Kevan Walsh – ESR – Auckland, New Zealand

 

 


Objectives:

As part of research carried out to reassess the methods used to estimate firing distance we explored some of the traditional beliefs regarding shotgun patterns. Two particular aspects that were investigated were;

  1. The underlying statistical distribution of pellet patterns.

  2. The effect of deformation of lead pellets on the pattern.

Methodology:

(1) We undertook a study to test whether or not shotgun pellet patterns followed a Normal distribution. Shotshells were loaded with #4 lead pellets and fired over 10 and 15 metres. The Cartesian coordinates for each pellet hole in a pattern were recorded and Normal probability plots for each of the vertical and horizontal coordinates were plotted.

(2) It is popularly believed that the spread of shotgun pellets in flight is principally dictated by the differing aerodynamic effects upon individual pellets which have differing degrees of deformation imparted to them upon firing and through contact with the barrel.
We explored this concept through a series of experiments involving loading coloured #4 lead pellets into the shotshell. Pellets in different locations in the shotshell were coloured differently. The pellets were fired vertically downwards over 15 metres into media such as water and gelatine to collect the pellets in a manner that did not damage them as a consequence of striking a solid target. The colour of each pellet and the Cartesian coordinates of the point at which it came to rest were recorded. The relative deformation of each pellet was also determined. The relationships between pellet deformation, pellet location in the shotshell and pellet location on the target were explored.

Results:

(1) In general the vertical and horizontal coordinates were approximately Normally distributed.
(2) A relationship was observed between the location of the pellet in the shotshell and the location on the target. The outermost pellets in the shotshell were the outermost pellets in the pattern. A relationship was observed between the location of the pellet in the shotshell and the resultant deformation of the pellet. The most deformed pellets were from the lower central core of pellets in the shotshell.

Conclusions:

(1) This study supports the view that shotgun patterns have a bivariate Normal distribution.

(2) This study did not show that there was any relationship between the degree of deformation of the pellets and their location on the target, which challenges traditional understanding of shotgun pellet distribution.
 

2:05 PM

 

 

The Identification of Impressed Cartridge Case Crimp Marks on Fired Bullets in a Casework Application

 

 

Michael Barnes – California Department of Justice – Redding, CA

 

 

 
An example of the reconstructive value of identifying bullets to specific cartridge cases will be discussed. Previous research published in the literature indicates that unique characteristics are imparted on a bullet by the case mouth with Winchester ammunition. Two Winchester bullets, each with a cannelure, and each damaged by striking a separate participant in a shooting incident, were examined and compared to cartridge cases located in separate chambers of a recovered revolver. Assuming certain facts, the sequence of firing could be established. The theory of an attempted murder and then suicide was not supported by this examination. The technique for producing test toolmarks, agreement observed during the comparisons and consideration of subclass influence during the comparison process will be presented

 

2:30 PM

 

BREAK – Held in Vendor / Exhibitor Area – Grand Ballroom B & C

Sponsored by: AFTE 2007 Host Committee

     

3:00 PM

 

DOOR PRIZE DRAWINGS

     

3:10 PM

 

WEB Databases for the Firearms Examiner

 

 

Ruprecht Nennstiel - Bundeskriminalamt (BKA) – Germany

   
Objectives: Since the beginning of 2007, 3 new WEB databases are available via the Internet for the firearms examiner:
  • MoF (Markings on Firearms): a database to determine the meaning of a marking found on a gun, including the possibility to post unknown markings to the community
  • FIRETYDE (Firearms Type (=Class) Determination): a database to determine make and model of a firearm from marks found on fired bullets and cases. This database includes graphs of the typical appearance of marks as they appear on fired cartridges.
  • CALIBER: a database to determine the caliber of a cartridge case from simple measurements, including the possibility to determine a standardized caliber name.

Methodology: All databases are available through the Internet free of charge for registered users only. The databases will be administered by the BKA. Forensic Science Department.
Firearm labs all over the world are invited to become registered users.

Results: The presentation gives an "online" demonstration of the databases. Printed application forms will be distributed for the interested audience. Application forms, however, are also available at https://www.forensic-firearms.bund.de
Select > Login > User Registration
(Remark: don't forget to enter https as part of the address into your browser!)

Conclusions: The new WEB databases hopefully may prove to be useful working tools for the forensic firearms examiner.


 

3:40 PM

 

Santa Ana Case Study

 

 

Rocky Edwards – Santa Ana Police Department – Santa Ana, CA

    Objectives: Discussion of the Santa Ana Case Study
  • Background
  • Problems dealing with overwhelming shooting incidents
  • Unique steps taken to deal with those issues
  • Techniques resulting in tremendous success using the IBIS System
  • Significant increase in IBIS Hits
  • Better understanding of what the IBIS Hits mean

Methodology: The city of Santa Ana, California is about 24 square miles in diameter with over 100 active Hispanic and Asian Gangs. With over 2500 firearm related incidents, the Santa Ana Police Department's one Firearms Examiner and two part time assistants had to come up with unique techniques to help combat the odds in dealing with this situation. These techniques such as Expedited Report Writing, Flow Charting, Mapping and Training of Crime Scene Personnel the IBIS system have helped to prioritize the workload of the Forensic Firearms Section.

Results: What has resulted from the techniques mentioned, the Santa Ana Police Department currently has nearly 800 IBIS Cold Case Hits with 630 of those hits being in the past 24 months. Because of the success of the program the coordination between the Firearms Unit and the Gang Unit has improved. The Gang Unit for the Santa Ana Police Department actually assigns cases to their detectives based on IBIS Hits.

Conclusions: These techniques and perspectives on report writing, flow charting, mapping techniques and procedures are presented as a way to show that things can be done to improve the effectiveness of the Firearms Unit. This is presented to the members in order to create innovative thinking toward ways to improve the industry and provide better results for the detectives and the communities they serve.


 

4:15 PM

 

How to Check a Czeck

 

 

Michael Appel – California Department of Justice – Fresno, CA

   
In casework, the firearm examiner may occasionally come across an unmarked or homemade firearm. Without a factory stamp indicating the caliber of the firearm, one must make these determinations by other means. This becomes even more crucial if test firing is requested. This paper will detail a particular homicide case involving an unmarked firearm and the steps taken and lessons learned to identify what cartridge(s) it was chambered for.

4:30 PM

 

IPT – Identification of Production Toolmarks

 

 

Lars Hebsgaard – Danish National Police, Forensic Dept. – Copenhagen, Denmark

    Objectives: New method which shows practicable production toolmarks inside cartridge cases.

Methodology: I will show, that in several steps of production, specific toolmarks will be left inside the cartridge cases from the tools / mandrels.

Results: By examining different makes of ammunition, the study has shown that the majority of cartridges in a randomly chosen box of ammunition are produced by the same mandrel.

Conclusions: My study has shown that it is possible to link cartridges to the mandrel that have been used in the production.



 

5:10 PM

 

END OF DAILY TECHNICAL SESSION

 

  Workshops

 

Time

Workshop / Armorer’s Course

Location

6:00 PM-9:00 PM

Serial Number Restorations – Magnaflux ®

Seacliff A

  This half-day workshop will introduce students to restoration of serial numbers using Magna-flux. Each participant will be acquainted with the background, technology and technique for this methodology.
 

6:00 PM-9:00 PM

Silencer Design

Seacliff C

  This half-day workshop will acquaint participants with various silencer designs, effectiveness, means of testing and legal implications. The most recent technology will be introduced and discussed.
 

6:00 PM-9:00 PM

Critical Incident Stress Management

Seacliff D

  David Wee, M.S.S.W., is employed by the City of Berkeley, Department of Health and Human Services, Mental Health Division, Mobile Crisis Team and Compliance Program. He serves as Program Supervisor of the Mobile Crisis Team, which provides consultation to emergency service personnel concerning emergency mental health intervention. He is also responsible for coordination of psychological support services to emergency services personal and delivery of mental health services to citizens following disasters.

This half-day workshop will introduce participants to the concept of critical incident stress management (CISM). One of the common, now archaic, techniques for dealing with stress related to critical incidents was to detach from them. It is becoming quite apparent that detachment, while immediately helpful, has a greater likelihood of deleterious long-term effects extending to all avenues of our lives. This workshop will help participants to be more aware of ways in which critical incident stress can be managed such that they are not paralyzed from accomplishing the task while maintaining long-term mental health that is vibrant.
 



blue line

HOME | The Association | Members Area | Membership Info 
AFTE Journal | Online Payments | Examiner Resources | Training Seminar 
Message Board | Job Postings | Forensic Links
| HELP  

Copyright © 2006 Association of Firearm and Tool Mark Examiners (AFTE).
All rights reserved.  Revised: May 31, 2007.